Ceramic vs. Enamel vs. Stainless Steel: Which Campfire Mug is Right for Your Brand?

Since 1995, we’ve shipped custom drinkware to every corner of the country. We’ve learned that the “best” mug isn’t just about the logo—it’s about how that mug feels in your customer’s hand when it arrives.

When you’re ordering in bulk, you’re choosing the “handshake” of your brand. Here is the real-world breakdown of our three most popular campfire styles.

The Heritage Original: Enamel

Letchworth - Bulk Custom Printed 16oz Powder Coated Carbon Steel Mug

The Vibe: Retro, Authentic, “Lived-In.”

Enamel mugs (porcelain-coated steel) are the ultimate nostalgia play. They are the mugs you remember from old-school scouting trips and family camping weekends.

The Reality: Enamel is unique because it “ages” with you. While the steel core is tough, the porcelain coating can chip over time if it’s handled roughly. For many heritage brands, those chips are a badge of honor—giving the mug a “lived-in” vintage character.

Best For: Breweries, adventure brands, and anyone leaning into a 70s or 80s retro aesthetic.

Pros: Extremely lightweight and carries that unmistakable “clink” when you set it down.

The Modern Workhorse: Stainless Steel

The Vibe: Sleek, Performance-Driven, Unbeatable Value.

If you think stainless steel has to be expensive, think again. Our stainless campfire mugs are surprisingly affordable while offering a modern look that ceramic and enamel can’t touch.

The Reality: These are incredibly durable and offer a crisp, clean surface for your logo. They don’t chip, they don’t crack, and they keep coffee hot.

Best For: Modern tech brands, construction crews, and outdoor retreats.

Why we love them: You get a high-tech look and unbreakable performance without breaking the budget.

The Heavyweight Champion: Ceramic

The Vibe: Substantial, Premium, Classic.

There is a reason the ceramic speckled mug is the gold standard for campfire gear. It has a weight to it that screams “quality.” When a client pulls this out of the box, they feel the value immediately.

The Reality: These are thick-walled and built for heat retention. They offer that iconic “speckled” glaze that everyone recognizes.

Best For: High-end corporate gifts, coffee shops, and brands that want a “heavy” premium feel.

Pro-Tip: Because these are substantial, they ship in reinforced packaging to ensure they arrive in perfect condition.

The Quick-Comparison Guide

If you want…	Choose…
A “Substantial” Premium Hand-Feel	Ceramic
The Best Durability for the Price	Stainless Steel
Authentic Vintage Character	Enamel

Why Experience Matters

At Campfire Premiums, we don’t just print mugs—we manage the entire experience. From Elma, NY, to your front door, we handle the logistics of high-volume shipping, so you don’t have to worry about a thing. We’ve been perfecting this process for over 30 years to ensure your brand arrives looking exactly like it should.

By Jean MasmanIn About Us, Life Style

Printed in the 716: Custom Drinkware for WNY

March 19, 2026

Why Shopping Local for Your Custom Drinkware Matters in Buffalo

At Campfire Premiums, we aren’t just an online shop—we’re your neighbors right here in the Buffalo area. Whether you’re grabbing a morning coffee in Elmwood Village or planning a summer wedding at Letchworth, we believe the gear you use should tell a story.

This past year, we’ve been hard at work updating our shop to make sure our local partners—the coffee shops, breweries, and schools that make WNY great—get the fastest service and the highest quality bulk printing. From our classic Enamel Camp Mugs to our stainless steel travel tumblers, every piece is printed with the Buffalo spirit in mind.

Have a local event or a business launch coming up? Stop by our site and let’s grow the 716 together.

By Jean MasmanIn About Us

Post Industrial (PIR) and Post Consumer (PCR)

June 1, 2023

Post Industrial (PIR) and Post Consumer (PCR) are two types of recycled plastics.

Post-Industrial Polypropylene Material: Plastic that was never used by consumers is referred to as post-industrial. This extra plastic is a byproduct of production and is produced for a number of different reasons. Some scrap is created when goods are contoured or when manufacturing is altered along a line. Other times, scrap is produced when essential inspections on the printing standards and product quality are made. This plastic can be simpler to gather and recycle because it never leaves the manufacturing environment.

Post-consumer resin, or PCR for short (post-consumer recycled), is a type of environmentally friendly packaging created from recycled plastics, most frequently PET and HDPE. Recycled objects like bottles, milk jugs, buckets, and industrial goods may be disassembled, melted, and rebuilt to form a resin substance that is then used to build a new product—PCR packaging—instead of being disposed of in a nearby landfill.

With the help of old recycled plastics, many “new” items are continuously created using PCR packaging. Additionally, compared to items made from virgin resin, post-consumer recycled manufacturing uses fewer fossil fuels and raw materials in its composition, according to the United States Environmental Protection Agency (EPA).

With PCR and PIR, manufacturers may create items of the same high caliber and affordability as those made from virgin resin while having fewer adverse effects on the environment. When it comes to protection, functionality, and strength, recycled plastics are on par with normal plastic film in grade.

Our PCR and PIR drinkware comply with FDA guidelines, making them safe for use in drink contact.

By Jean MasmanIn About Us

Shipping Delays

August 31, 2021

Shipping the past year has been a nightmare. Products have sold out and not been available for months. Shipping to customers takes longer. And it does not look like it will be getting any better- in fact it looks like it will get worse.

I cannot keep up with the stock outages on our site- I recommend emailing me to confirm stock and if I confirm it ORDER it right away! Stock confirmed in the morning is wiped out and gone by the afternoon. I cannot control what my suppliers have on hand- and we are all trying as hard as we can to keep everyone updated. If something you order is out of stock I do send you an email letting you know it is backordered and when I expect it to come in.

Next issue is restocking- I just read an article that said pre pandemic I (or my suppliers) could count on getting products on time about 60% of the time- even pre-pandemic shipments were not at 100% on time. Now- they are lucky to arrive 40% of the time as scheduled. A major port in China is closed. There are 44 container ships sitting off the coast of California as I write this today. There are not enough people in port to unload them- and even if they did there are not enough truckers to get the products to whoever needs them.

Add to all this a major hurricane. The NY Times published this story: https://www.nytimes.com/2021/08/31/business/hurricane-ida-supply-chain-shortages.html So even the unreliable infrastructure we had to get product is now shaken.

I have most suppliers quoting me a three weeks before they can even get me blanks. That is stock in hand for them. They are so over run with orders. One of my biggest suppliers is quoting me two MONTHS before they can get me product.

Bottom line- if you need product for the holidays you need to have already ordered it- or order it TODAY!

By Jean MasmanIn About Us

What’s the Difference?

February 19, 2021

You may be looking at all our different enamel mugs and asking “what’s the difference?” Here is a comparison for you.

Allegany vs Geneseo

Our #1 camp mug is our Allegany. It has a rolled stainless steel rim and a speckled exterior. The black interior is a nice contrast. Minimum order is 100 pieces- starting at $5.25 each. The Geneseo also has a rolled stainless rim and speckled exterior- but has a white interior. Our Geneseo has a minimum order of only 48 mugs and starts at $6.50 each mug.

Our Potsdam has a rolled stainless rim and a solid exterior. As opposed to the speckled exterior of our Geneseo. They both have a black interior. The minimum order for our Potsdam is 60 mugs and starts at $7 each.

Our Letchworth is closest to the original camp mugs/ cowboy mugs you remember. It has a speckled exterior and a rolled rim and handle. The rim and interior match the exterior of the mug. The Letchworth has a minimum order of 64 and starts at $6.24 each.

The Camp Mug is one of our original camp mugs (not THE original- just the first one we carried) It is smaller than our Letchworth- the Letchworth is 16oz and the Camp Mug is 12oz. They have really gone up in price from my suppliers and we no longer carry them- I would go with the Letchworth or one of our other mugs that we offer.

This brings us to another original- our Safari mug- we sold a lot of these back in the beginning. But our cost has skyrocketed from our supplier. The Safari mugs were all solid white with colored rims. They were 12oz and came in a lot of great rim colors. This mug also went way up in price and we do not carry it except for special orders. Our Country cup is 16oz and comes solid colors with a black rim. With a minimum of 72 and starting at $7.19 each they are a great alternative. The country cup comes in several great colors- all with a black rim. Both the Safari and Country cup are solid white interior and exterior.

As for their similarities: They are all enameled steel. That is, they are steel mugs with an enamel coating to give them color. This makes them lightweight and gives them that old time look. Our enamel mugs are hand dipped- and colors may vary on the body, handles and rims. They are all great for any old time country or retro program. These old fashioned mugs are ideal for for outfitters, outdoor events and other camping related shops and promotions. By using old fashioned mugs like these you give your brand the look that it has been around a long time-just like they have been.

All are hand printed here in the USA. All our prices include your one color, one location logo unless otherwise noted in the description. As hand printed items we recommend hand washing to preserve your logo.

As always, I am happy to answer any questions– I hope this helps clear up some confusion. Thank you!

Menu

Mini Cart